Key takeaway
Before any estimate, run three checks that take fifteen minutes: verify the DCWP home improvement license, look up the DOB filing history, and get the insurance certificate in your hands. Then use the eleven questions below. The single biggest red flag in NYC is a large deposit demanded before work starts: a licensed contractor with real cash flow does not need your money to buy materials.
Want to skip the vetting? Our license and certificates come with the quote.
Free on-site estimate. Written, fixed-price quote within 48 hours.

In this guide
The three checks before any estimate
These take fifteen minutes and eliminate most of the field before anyone visits your apartment. They work on any contractor in any borough.
One: the license. Home improvement contractors working in the five boroughs must be licensed by the Department of Consumer Worker Protection. Use the DCWP license lookup and check the complaint history while you are there. An unlicensed contractor is not a bargain, they are a contractor with no trust fund behind them and no mediation process when things go wrong.
Two: the filing history. Search the contractor and their license numbers in the Department of Buildings records. You are looking for permits actually filed and closed out, not just opened. A contractor who claims twenty years of kitchen work with no DOB trail has either been working unpermitted or not doing the work.
Three: the certificate of insurance. Ask for the COI before the walkthrough, and if you are in a co-op or condo, ask them to issue one naming your building. A contractor who cannot produce insurance in a day has a problem you do not want to inherit. We hand ours over before anyone asks twice, and you can read about what a takeover looks like when the last contractor skipped all three of these steps in what to do when a contractor abandons the job.
The red flags table
Hiring signals, side by side
| Green flag | Walk away | |
|---|---|---|
| License number | Volunteered before you ask | Not offered, or does not verify |
| Deposit | None or small, milestone-based | 10 percent or more before demo |
| The quote | Itemized, brands and models listed | One number on one page |
| Payment | Credit card or check with a paper trail | Cash discount offered |
| Timeline | Written start and finish, penalties discussed | Starts whenever, vague on end |
| Permits | I file and manage it, it is in the quote | You pull the permit yourself |
| Pressure | Take the quote, think about it | Same-day signing discount |
License number
Green flagVolunteered before you ask
Walk awayNot offered, or does not verify
Deposit
Green flagNone or small, milestone-based
Walk away10 percent or more before demo
The quote
Green flagItemized, brands and models listed
Walk awayOne number on one page
Payment
Green flagCredit card or check with a paper trail
Walk awayCash discount offered
Timeline
Green flagWritten start and finish, penalties discussed
Walk awayStarts whenever, vague on end
Permits
Green flagI file and manage it, it is in the quote
Walk awayYou pull the permit yourself
Pressure
Green flagTake the quote, think about it
Walk awaySame-day signing discount
The eleven questions
Each question has two answers: the one a good contractor gives, and the one that should end the conversation. We can say that because these are, one for one, the standards we hold ourselves to.
1. Who will be in my apartment on a normal Tuesday?
A good answer sounds like: A named lead and the same crew for the whole job. You will meet the lead before the contract.
End the conversation if you hear: Depends on the day, we send whoever is available. Rotating strangers with keys to your home is how small problems become invisible ones.
2. What is your DCWP license number?
A good answer sounds like: Said out loud, immediately, spelled correctly, with an offer to send the license and COI.
End the conversation if you hear: Any version of hesitation, or a number that does not come back live in the lookup.
3. How many jobs like mine have you filed with the DOB in the last year?
A good answer sounds like: A specific count, with buildings or streets you could verify, and comfort describing the filing process.
End the conversation if you hear: We usually do not need permits for this. For work that clearly requires filing, that answer is disqualifying.
4. What exactly does the quote include, and what is an allowance?
A good answer sounds like: Walks you through line items and states which numbers are allowances, with a real dollar figure each allowance covers.
End the conversation if you hear: Everything is included, do not worry. The change orders arrive after demo.
5. What happens when we find something behind the wall?
A good answer sounds like: A change-order process in writing, priced before the work proceeds, plus a realistic heads-up about what your building's age makes likely.
End the conversation if you hear: We will figure it out when we get there, with an hourly shrug.
6. What is the payment schedule?
A good answer sounds like: Milestones tied to completed, inspectable work. No deposit, or a small one. Card or check accepted.
End the conversation if you hear: A large check before anything happens, or a cash discount. Both are the classic setup for the disappearing act.
7. Who handles the board package and the building?
A good answer sounds like: We assemble the COI, license copies, scope memo, and drawings. You sign and pay the building's fees.
End the conversation if you hear: The board is your problem. In a co-op that contractor has never done a co-op job.
8. How do you protect the apartment and the hallway?
A good answer sounds like: Specific answers: floor protection, dust walls, a negative-air machine where it matters, daily cleanup, the building's debris route.
End the conversation if you hear: We keep it clean. Renovation dust in a Manhattan building travels two floors without containment.
9. What hours will you work?
A good answer sounds like: The building's hours, stated back to you, with noisy work sequenced inside the allowed window.
End the conversation if you hear: Eight to six, every day. In most co-ops that answer would get your job shut down by Thursday.
10. What is not included that I might expect to be?
A good answer sounds like: An honest list: appliances sometimes, painting beyond the scope, board fees, the expeditor if the job did not need one at quote time.
End the conversation if you hear: Nothing, it is all-inclusive. Nobody's quote is all-inclusive.
11. Can I talk to two recent clients in similar buildings?
A good answer sounds like: Yes, same day, with projects close to yours in scope and building type.
End the conversation if you hear: Client privacy prevents that. Every licensed working contractor has happy clients who take reference calls.
Run these eleven questions on us. Call (626) 657-4512.
Free on-site estimate. Written, fixed-price quote within 48 hours.
What the contract must include
A real renovation contract is several pages and reads boring. It needs: the scope broken out line by line, materials by brand and model, the payment schedule tied to milestones, who files permits, the COI requirements, working hours, the change-order process, and a warranty in writing. If you are in a co-op, our co-op board approval guide covers the building-specific documents that attach to it.
New York caps what home improvement contractors can demand up front, and licensed ones know it. Our position is simpler than the legal line: no deposit. The fixed price is agreed in writing before work starts, payment follows progress, and the 48-hour quote window is in every contract.
How many quotes should you get
Three, and compare them line by line, never bottom line to bottom line. The 20 percent cheaper quote almost always has a smaller tile allowance, a missing waterproofing line, or permits excluded. To see what a comparable line-item structure looks like, read what a kitchen renovation costs in NYC and what a bathroom renovation costs, then hold every quote to that standard of detail. If you want to know who you are hiring beyond the paperwork, the about page is the founder story, including the bad contractor who started all this.
Frequently asked questions
How do I check if a NYC contractor is licensed?
Look them up on the NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection license search, which shows the license status and any complaint history. Home improvement contractors working in the five boroughs are required to hold this license. If the name you were given does not match a live license, that is the entire decision, no estimate needed.How much deposit should a contractor ask for?
As little as possible, and in New York a licensed contractor demanding a large deposit up front is a red flag, not a norm. Milestone-based payments tied to completed work protect you. Our own policy is no deposit at all: we start on the schedule and the written fixed price.Should I hire a general contractor or manage subs myself?
Managing subs yourself saves the GC markup and costs you the schedule, the coordination, and the single throat to choke when trades overlap. In Manhattan apartments, where board rules and building logistics punish scheduling mistakes, most people renovating a kitchen, a bathroom, or more should hire a GC. A single-room paint job is the honest exception.What should a contractor's contract include?
A scope broken out line by line, materials specified by brand and model, a payment schedule tied to milestones, the permit responsibility, insurance certificates naming your building, working hours, and a change-order process in writing. A one-page single-number document is an estimate, and the final bill will not match it.Should I get three quotes?
Three is right, and how you compare them matters more than the count. Line-item by line-item: the same tile allowance, the same waterproofing scope, the same permit line. A quote that is 20 percent lower is usually missing a scope line, not offering a better price.
Free on-site estimate. Fixed-price quote in 48 hours.
No deposit required. Written workmanship guarantee on every job. We answer phones 7 days a week, 7am to 7pm.